118 York Street, Cornwall, Ontario118 York Street(613) 932-1620Accepting New Patients

Emergency Dentistry

Cracked or Broken Filling: What to Do and How It Is Fixed

A filling that cracks, chips or breaks should be checked within days. Learn the signs, how urgent it is, how to protect the tooth and how it is repaired.

Close-up of healthy natural teeth

In brief

If a filling cracks or a piece breaks off, remove any loose fragment so you do not swallow it, rinse with warm salt water, chew on the other side and avoid hard, sticky and very cold foods. Call a dental office to have it checked within a few days, even if it does not hurt. Call the same day if the tooth is painful, a large part of the tooth broke with the filling, a sharp edge is cutting your cheek or tongue, or the gum is swollen. A small chip can sometimes be smoothed or patched; a filling with a crack running through it, or a tooth that has cracked around it, usually needs a new filling, an onlay (partial crown) or a crown.

Key takeaways

  • A cracked or broken filling is usually urgent rather than an emergency, but it should be checked within days.
  • No pain does not mean the tooth is safe. Cracks let bacteria leak under the filling, where decay can grow unseen.
  • Small chips can sometimes be smoothed or repaired; larger breaks usually need a new filling, an onlay or a crown.
  • Pain when you bite or release, lingering pain, or swelling suggests the tooth itself may be cracked or the nerve involved.
  • Grinding, very large old fillings and new decay are common reasons fillings crack.

If a filling cracks or a piece breaks off, take any loose fragment out of your mouth, rinse with warm salt water and chew on the other side. Call a dental office to have it checked within a few days, even if it does not hurt, and call the same day if there is pain, swelling, a sharp edge cutting your mouth, or a large part of the tooth has broken. A cracked or broken filling is usually urgent rather than an emergency, but the seal around the filling is no longer intact, and that lets decay and further cracks develop.

A filling does not always fall out in one piece. More often, a corner chips off while you are eating, a crack appears across an old filling, or the edge simply starts to feel rough. This guide covers what to do in the first few minutes, how to tell whether it is the filling or the tooth that has broken, why a broken filling with no pain still needs attention, and how dentists decide between patching, replacing or crowning the tooth.

If the whole filling came out and left an open hole, see our separate guide on what to do if a dental filling falls out.

What should you do right away if your filling breaks?

1. Remove any loose pieces

If you feel a hard fragment, take it out so it does not get swallowed or go down the wrong way. Swallowing a small piece of filling is almost always harmless. Inhaling one, which usually causes sudden coughing, is different and needs medical attention. You can keep the fragment in a small bag to show your dentist, especially if you are not sure whether it is filling or tooth.

2. Rinse gently

Rinse with warm water, or warm salt water (about half a teaspoon of salt in a cup of warm water), to clear away food and any small particles.

3. Check the tooth carefully

Look in a mirror if you can. Note whether part of the filling is missing, whether there is a visible crack, whether the edge is sharp, and whether the gum around the tooth looks red or swollen. Run your tongue over it gently, but avoid poking at it with fingers or tools.

4. Protect the area

Chew on the other side and avoid hard, sticky, very cold, very hot or sugary foods. If a sharp edge is catching your tongue or cheek, press a small piece of orthodontic wax or sugar-free gum over it. Pharmacy temporary filling material can cover a small gap for a few days, but it is a stopgap, not a repair.

5. Call a dental office

Tell the team what happened, whether the tooth hurts, and whether there is any swelling. That helps them decide how soon you should be seen. Our emergency dentistry page explains how urgent visits are handled at York Street Dental Centre.

What are the signs of a cracked filling?

Not every broken filling is obvious. A crack can be fine, or hidden between two teeth, and you may only notice small changes:

  • A rough, sharp or uneven edge that your tongue keeps going back to.
  • Floss that catches, frays or shreds in one particular spot.
  • Food packing into the same space after meals.
  • New sensitivity to cold drinks, sweets or cold air on a tooth that used to be comfortable.
  • A brief, sharp pain when you bite down or let go, especially on something firm.
  • A dark line or shadow around the edge of a white filling, or a visible line across a silver one.
  • A small piece missing that you notice when you look closely or a fragment you find while eating.

Some cracks cause no symptoms at all and are only found during a checkup or on an X-ray. That is one reason regular dental exams matter for teeth with older or larger fillings.

Is it the filling or the tooth that cracked?

This is the most important question, and it can be hard to answer at home.

What you notice What it may mean
Silver-grey fragment Usually a piece of an old amalgam filling
Tooth-coloured fragment A white (composite) filling or part of the tooth itself
Small chip at the edge of the filling Often a filling chip; sometimes the thin tooth edge beside it
Hole looks much larger than the old filling Part of the tooth has probably broken too
Pain when you bite or release The tooth itself may be cracked
Lingering ache or throbbing The nerve may be inflamed

Fillings and teeth often break together. Large fillings leave thin walls of natural tooth around them, and those walls are the weak point. A tooth that has cracked, rather than just the filling, may need more protection than a new filling can provide. Our article on why a tooth hurts when biting explains cracked tooth symptoms in more detail.

A piece of my filling broke off but there is no pain. Is that okay?

It is very common for a broken filling not to hurt, and many people are surprised by it. A painless break can happen because:

  • The break is small or shallow, so there is still plenty of tooth between the damaged area and the nerve.
  • The tooth has had a root canal, so it no longer has a living nerve to feel temperature or sweets.
  • The nerve has quietly lost vitality over time, which can mean an infection is developing without pain.
  • The crack is in the filling only, and the tooth beneath is still sealed for now.

No pain does not mean the tooth is safe. A crack or gap breaks the seal between the filling and the tooth. Bacteria can then leak underneath, where decay can grow without being seen and without hurting until it is quite advanced. A broken filling with no pain that is repaired within a few days usually needs a simpler fix than one left for months.

What happens if you leave a broken filling?

Leaving a broken filling for weeks or months can lead to:

  • Decay under the filling. This is sometimes called recurrent decay, and it is a common reason older fillings fail.
  • Further fracture. The thin walls around a broken filling can crack under normal chewing, sometimes below the gumline.
  • Nerve inflammation or infection, which may then need root canal treatment.
  • A bigger repair. What might have been a small patch can become a crown, a root canal or, rarely, an extraction.

This is why a few days is a sensible window, even when you feel fine.

How urgent is a broken filling?

Use this as a general guide. If you are unsure, call the office and describe what happened.

Situation How soon to get care
Small chip, no pain, no sharp edge Book a visit within a few days
Crack you can see or feel, mild sensitivity Book a visit within a few days
Sharp edge cutting your tongue or cheek Call the same day or next day
Large piece of filling or tooth broke off Call the same day or next day
Pain when biting, or pain that lingers after hot or cold Call the same day
Throbbing pain that starts on its own or wakes you at night Call the same day
Swollen gum or face, or fever Call the same day
Swelling spreading toward the eye, under the jaw or into the neck Go to the emergency department
Trouble breathing or swallowing Call 911

Swelling means infection may be spreading. See facial swelling and tooth pain for when to go to hospital, and what counts as a dental emergency for other urgent situations.

How do you protect the tooth until your appointment?

  • Keep it clean. Brush gently twice a day with fluoride toothpaste and rinse after meals to clear food from the area.
  • Floss carefully. If floss catches on the broken edge, slide it out sideways instead of pulling it back up.
  • Chew on the other side. Thin tooth walls around a broken filling can crack under pressure.
  • Choose soft foods. Avoid nuts, ice, hard candy, popcorn, crusty bread and sticky foods such as caramel or toffee.
  • Avoid temperature extremes and sugar, which are the most common triggers for sensitivity.
  • Use a sensitivity toothpaste if the tooth is sensitive.
  • Take over-the-counter pain relief as directed on the package, if you need it and it is safe for you.

Things not to do

  • Do not use household glue or superglue to hold a piece in place.
  • Do not put aspirin directly on the tooth or gum. It can burn the tissue.
  • Do not file or scrape the edge yourself.
  • Do not keep testing the tooth by biting on it to see if it still hurts.

Why do fillings crack or break?

Fillings are strong, but they are not permanent. Common reasons they crack include:

  • Age and wear. Every filling is under chewing forces many times a day. Older fillings eventually wear, chip or lose their seal.
  • Large fillings. The bigger the filling, the less natural tooth is left to support it, and the more the remaining walls flex.
  • Grinding and clenching. Night-time grinding puts heavy, repeated force on fillings and teeth. A custom night guard can help protect them.
  • New decay at the edge of the filling, which weakens the bond.
  • Biting something hard, such as ice, a popcorn kernel, an olive pit or a hard candy.
  • Temperature changes and expansion in older amalgam fillings, which can contribute to small cracks in the tooth around them over many years.
  • Trauma, such as a fall or a blow to the mouth.

How is a cracked or broken filling fixed?

Your appointment usually follows these steps:

  1. Questions about what happened and any pain or sensitivity.
  2. An examination of the filling, the tooth and the gums, often with magnification and a bite test.
  3. An X-ray in many cases, to check for decay under the filling and look at the nerve and root.
  4. An explanation of the options, with estimated fees, before any treatment starts.
  5. The repair, once you agree on a plan.

Possible repairs

  • Smoothing or polishing. A tiny chip at the edge with a sound filling and no decay can sometimes just be smoothed.
  • Repairing the existing filling. If a small section has broken and the rest of the filling is well sealed, a dentist may bond new tooth-coloured material to it rather than removing the whole filling. This keeps more natural tooth.
  • Replacing the filling. If the crack runs through the filling, the seal has failed, or there is decay underneath, the old filling is removed and a new dental filling is placed.
  • An onlay (partial crown). When a broken filling is too large to replace reliably but enough strong tooth remains, an onlay covers and protects one or more of the chewing cusps without covering the whole tooth. See onlay vs crown for how the two compare.
  • A crown. If the tooth itself is cracked or very little tooth is left, a crown holds the tooth together and spreads chewing force. Our guide to dental crown vs filling explains how dentists decide.
  • Root canal treatment. If decay or a crack has reached the nerve, the tooth may need a root canal before it is restored.

Repair, onlay or crown: how dentists decide

Factor Points toward a new filling Points toward an onlay or crown
Size of the break Small to moderate Large, or involving a cusp
Remaining tooth Thick, healthy walls Thin walls or a cracked cusp
Crack in the tooth None found Crack line in the tooth itself
Root canal history No Yes, especially on a back tooth
Grinding or heavy bite Mild Significant

These are general patterns, not rules. The right repair depends on what your dentist finds when the tooth is examined.

Should old silver fillings be replaced before they crack?

Not automatically. Health Canada’s position is that amalgam fillings that are in good condition do not need to be removed, because drilling out a sound filling removes healthy tooth too. Fillings are usually replaced when they are broken, leaking, have decay around them, or when the tooth needs more support. If an old amalgam filling breaks, it is commonly replaced with a tooth-coloured material, but the choice depends on the size and location of the filling.

What affects the cost of fixing a broken filling?

We do not quote fees without examining the tooth, because the repair depends on what is found. Cost factors include:

  • whether the filling can be repaired or needs full replacement,
  • how many surfaces of the tooth are involved,
  • the material used,
  • whether there is decay under the old filling, and
  • whether an onlay, crown or root canal is needed instead of a filling.

Many private dental plans cover part of the cost of fillings, and the office can send a predetermination for larger treatment such as an onlay or crown. York Street Dental Centre offers direct billing to many insurance plans. If you have Canadian Dental Care Plan (CDCP) coverage, ask our team what applies to your repair, since coverage details can change.

How can you help your fillings last longer?

  • Brush twice a day with fluoride toothpaste and clean between your teeth every day.
  • Limit how often you snack on or sip sugary foods and drinks.
  • Avoid chewing ice, pens, hard candy and other hard objects.
  • If you grind or clench, ask your dentist about a night guard.
  • Keep regular checkups so worn or leaking fillings can be found and fixed before they break.

Getting a broken filling checked in Cornwall

A cracked or broken filling is simplest to fix early, before decay or a crack has a chance to spread. York Street Dental Centre is a family dental office at 118 York Street in Cornwall, convenient for patients in downtown Cornwall, Eamer’s Corners and Riverdale, and for those coming from Glen Walter, Lakeview Heights and St. Andrews West. We welcome new patients, so you do not need to already be on our patient list to call.

When you come in, we will check the filling and the tooth around it, explain why it broke, and go over the repair options and estimated fees before starting.

Call us about a cracked or broken filling

If a piece of your filling broke off, or you think a filling is cracked, call York Street Dental Centre at (613) 932-1620. If the tooth is comfortable and you can wait a few days, you can also request an appointment online. You can read more about dental fillings at our office.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if a filling breaks and you leave it?

The gap or crack lets food and bacteria under the filling, so decay can spread beneath it where you cannot see it. The thin tooth walls around a broken filling can also crack further. Over weeks or months, a simple repair can turn into a crown, root canal treatment or, rarely, an extraction.

A piece of my filling broke off but there is no pain. Can it wait?

It can usually wait a few days, but not weeks. Many broken fillings do not hurt, especially if the break is small, the filling is shallow, or the tooth has had a root canal. Book a visit within the next few days and protect the tooth until then.

How do I know if my filling is cracked?

Common signs are a rough or sharp edge your tongue keeps finding, floss that catches or shreds in one spot, food packing into the same area, new sensitivity to cold or sweets, a dark line around the filling, or a brief sharp pain when you bite down or let go. Some cracks have no symptoms and are only found on an exam or X-ray.

Can a cracked filling be repaired instead of replaced?

Sometimes. If only a small edge has chipped and the rest of the filling is sound with no decay underneath, a dentist may smooth it or bond new material to the existing filling. If the crack runs through the filling, the seal has failed, or there is decay underneath, the filling is normally replaced.

Is it the filling that cracked, or my tooth?

It can be either, or both. Silver fragments are usually old amalgam filling. Tooth-coloured fragments may be a white filling or part of the tooth itself. A jagged piece, a much larger hole, or pain when biting suggests the tooth may have cracked, which can change the repair. Your dentist will check with a close examination and often an X-ray.

Should I have my old silver fillings replaced before they crack?

Not automatically. Health Canada does not recommend removing intact amalgam fillings that are in good condition, because removal itself takes away healthy tooth. Fillings are replaced when they are broken, leaking, have decay around them, or the tooth needs more support.

What is a partial crown, and is it better than a filling?

A partial crown, often called an onlay, covers one or more of the chewing cusps of a back tooth without covering the whole tooth. It can be a good option when a broken filling is too large to replace reliably with another filling, but enough healthy tooth remains that a full crown is not needed.

Sources

  • Canadian Dental Association — Dental Fillings
  • Health Canada — The Safety of Dental Amalgam
  • American Dental Association (MouthHealthy) — Fillings
  • American Association of Endodontists — Cracked Teeth

About the author

This article was written by the York Street Dental Centre Team and reviewed for clinical accuracy by the York Street Dental Centre dental team. York Street Dental Centre is a family dental office at 118 York Street, Cornwall, Ontario K6J 3Y8, providing general, preventive, restorative, and cosmetic dental care for patients of all ages.

Our articles explain common dental questions in plain language, cite reputable health and government sources where relevant, and are updated when guidance changes. Read our editorial policy or learn more about our practice.

This content is intended for general educational purposes and does not replace an examination, diagnosis or personalized treatment recommendation from a dental professional.

Ready to book your visit?

New patients are welcome. Call us or request an appointment online.